I was unable to find a post that collaborated the results of Mr. Pinchy's wishes so I thought I'd start the forum post myself. (There is one post here about what people have gotten from Mr. Pinchy, but it's not useful for getting statistical information about Mr. Pinchy's wishes out of it. There is also a post on Thottbot, but that post is also difficult to read and get statistical information out of) While the possible results of Mr. Pinchy's wishes are well known and documented on this website as well as others, there seems be no information on the statistics (i.e. results) of the 3 wishes. Personally, I'm trying to get the elusive status symbol that is the Magical Crawdad Box (on my alt Bradd) and have yet to see what the chances of getting it is. In the spirit of the Daily Quest Fish Catch Rate, I was hoping people could post the results of Mr. Pinchy's wishes.
Posts should be formatted in the following format (for clarity's sake):
Mr. Pinchy #: Wish Result 1, Wish Result 2, Wish Result 3
If you've caught multiple Mr. Pinchy's, please post the results for each Mr. Pinchy's wishes separately. (If you forgot what all you've gotten, just start with whatever Mr. Pinchy number you're currently on)
Wish results should be posted as the following:
Benevolent = Benevolent Mr. Pinchy
Furious = Furious Mr. Pinchy
Gift = Mr. Pinchy's Gift (Containing Mana & Healing Potions)
Pet = Magical Crawdad Box
Blessing = Mr. Pinchy's Blessing
On Deathxtreme, my results were:
Mr. Pinchy 1: Gift, Benevolent, Pet
I'll post the results of Bradd, my alt, later tonight after I make my third wish...