((Advertisement))

[Fishing] Mr. Pinchy's Wishes

1…91011…16

  1. Freebeer <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr. Pinchy #3

    1) Furious
    2) Blessing
    3) Blessing

    My friends Mr. Pinchy #1:

    1) Gift
    2) Gift
    3) Pet.....sigh

  2. Marlene <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    How many catches does it take to get Mr. Pinchy? I've been hitting there almost every night.

    No one is fishing there on my server so I was able to hit 12-15 of the node in one night. They just kept popping.

    Should he be like the rare fish? Thousands of catches or am I just unlucky?

    Let me know.

    Marlene

  3. kamitomo <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr. Pinchy #1:
    1) Blessing
    2) Benevolent
    3) Pet

    Btw, caught Mr. Pinchy on 3rd cast... gee, I thought this was supposed to be hard? ;)

  4. Krahn <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    OOooooo Mr. Pinchy...

    Mr. Pinchy #1:
    1) Gift
    2) Gift
    3) Gift

    Let's just say I was the one Furious...

    Mr. Pinchy #2
    1) Pet
    2) Gift
    3) Blessing

    As superstition for my 2nd one, I went to Orgrimmar and wished next to Thrall. It was actually during the pre-Wrath event where Thrall was with Grommosh outside the Arena. Superstition indeed!

  5. triper99 <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    After 1000ish catches in Skettis I finally landed my first Mr. Pinchy, I'll update this post as I use the wishes.

    Wish #1: Furious
    Wish #2: PET!!!!!!! OMG SALTY!!!
    Wish #3: TBA

  6. Mala <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    after is fished my first mr. pinchy, I decided to keep on fishing until my lure fades. +100 lures have been still expensive at this time (the fishing-daily was introduced later). and guess what I got! RIGHT! a second mr. pinchy. 2 pinchy's in less than 5 minutes :D

    Mr. Pinchy #1
    Wish1: Blessing
    Wish2: Pet
    Wish3: Pet

    Mr. Pinchy #2
    Wish1: Pet
    Wish2: Furious
    Wish3: Pet

    makes me feel sad, that I had to sell 3 pets when I read this forum :)

    PS: less than 200 catches for the 2 pinchys. but I get the payback for that on the OTDGW-Achievement -.-

  7. Oakthorn <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Only caught him once so far, and I'm overdue to try again (haven't tried in over a week):

    Wish #1: Gift
    Wish #2: Gift
    Wish #3: Furious

  8. moogleroyalty <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    I was lucky enough to get Mr. Pinchy in one cast!

    Wish #1: Gift
    Wish #2: Furious
    Wish #3: Pet~ ^^;

  9. Samessa <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr. Pinchy 2: Furious, Benevolent, Pet

  10. Senthea <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    So I caught my first pinchy last week:

    Wish #1: Gift
    Wish #2: Gift
    Wish #3: Gift

    Pretty lame -.-

    Will post once I get my next one...

  11. thiealze <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    On my other character, Arbre, my druid:

    1 Mr. Pinchy:

    Wish 1: Magical Crawdad!!!
    Wish 2: Fort buff
    Wish 3: Mr. Pinchy's Gift

  12. Aineko <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Decided to poke it tonight now that I finally knew where from this site. <3 And since I'm a pet addict. Got Mr Pinchy on the 12th Highland pool I was fishing.

    Wish 1: Pet Surprisingly o_O

    I might not do the other wishes, just to keep him in my bank. <_< eheh

  13. Gamal <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Could have had 2 Pinchies, but I was unconcentrated and didnt loot (stepped back) the 2nd one.

    Mr Pinchy #1:

    1. Pet (lucky me)
    2. Furious
    3. Benevolent

  14. Wildhack <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Caught today:

    Wish #1: Furious
    Wish #2: Pet!
    Wish #3: (for the purposes of science): Blessing

  15. Rhamona <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    My second Mr. Pinchy:

    1. Gift
    2. Pet (woo!)
    3. Benevolent

  16. Kalfje <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    My third Mr Pinchy:

    1st wish: PET!!!!!!

    i think im gonna keep my mr pinchy just for the fun of it!

    btw i catched it in the first round i did after wrath came out..

    maybe they upped the droprate?

  17. Senthea <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Got my second Pinchy last weekend

    1st wish: Gift
    2nd wish: PET!!

    Retiring him to my bank along with crafty and ironjaw. Salty is in my sights now as I also won the fishing tournament last weekend, thanks to El and all those that come here for the tips!

  18. Prishe <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    I think they upped the drop rate on Mr Pinchy as well, it took me forever to get Mr Pinchy on my druide (pet after 3 Mr Pinchys), but I went fishing for him this weekend, got 2 Mr Pinchys in 5 minutes. I fished from about 10-15 pools, but I got both drops from Skettis.

    1st wish - Furious Mr Pinchy
    2nd wish - Furious Mr Pinchy >.<

    4 more trys for the pet !

  19. Adys <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    Got my first pinchy recently, been trying to catch a second one, no pet =(

    #1: Buff
    #2: Benevolent
    #3: Buff

  20. Dagnie <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Just got my Mr. Pinchy pet an hour ago, which finally prompted me to register for the site!

    I have fished Mr. Pinchy up once,
    Wish #1 was the Blessing
    Wish #2 was the Pet.
    (I'll edit in Wish #3 once I get it in 2 days)

    I was on the southwestern bank of Lake Jorune and had caught about 50+ Crawdads in that attempt, with 250+ Crawdads and a variety of Darters and Scroll cases overall. Buffs and equips included, I was at 492 fishing.

    Until I saw a link to El's Extreme Anglin' from WowHead or WowWiki or whichever it was, I had no idea there was such a great site bringing together all of us Azerothian fishermen :) Thanks so much to El for creating it and everyone else for all their helpful posts. This was my first real "worth bragging about" fishing accomplishment and I definitely couldn't have done it with you guys.

1…91011…16

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Forums Index