Another first time Pinchy person here. No pet.
1. Furious
2. Gift
3. Gift
I was pretty upset. But at least most people get their pets on the second Pinchy catching, even though that's completely arbitrary to the actually percent chance you have to gain the pet. zzz
Time for more Skettis fishing. See you guys in nine years.
EDIT: Second Pinchy. No luck.
1. Gift
2. Benevolent
3. Blessing
Ugh... See you guys in Skettis... Again...
Mr. Pinchy 1: Pet, Gift, Blessing
1st Mr. Pinchy:
wish #1: benevolent
wish #2: dunno yet
wish #3: dunno yet
wish me luck!
Yoco <Salty Cataclysm Investigator>, 3 years ago:Finally, after a seemingly eternal stretch of catching several hundreds of furious crawdads without catching mr Pinchy, I finally caught my third pinchy last week.
wish #1: benevolent
wish #2: Crawdad box!!!
wish #3: dunno yet
That's one less obstacle on the road to saltyhood ...
Just before i've HSd back to Dalaran to join our Naxx raid i found another school so i tought "Let's fish some more then i'll HS don't waste the schools." And on the 2nd cast i got pinchy and first wish was the pet! :)
Here comes back some return after i did thousands of casts for the 15 pound mud snapper.^^
1st wish: Pet
2nd wish: Benevolent
3rd wish: Benevolent
*Edited
ellwin <Angler>, 3 years ago:Mr. Pinchy 1: Blessing, Benevolent, Pet
1st Mr. Pinchy:
1 - gift
2 - pet
3 - blessing
I count myself lucky, after the first wish thought for sure i was going to have to fish up another!
I just got my first Mr. Pinchy today. Took him long enough to bite!
I used my first wish and got the Benevolent Mr. Pinchy. >.< Two more to go~
Tried fishing for him about 2 weeks ago
Tried maybe 4 spots.
Then a couple of days ago I went back and got him on the second cast.
Used first wish and got Magical Crawdad :)
Second wish was blessing
Have not used 3rd yet.
got my first mr. pinchy after 169 casts in blackwindlake and after reading the comments here i decided to fish the other pools that were up also. it gave a 2nd mr.pinchy 8 casts later :p
first wish was furious mr.pinchy
2nd wish in 4 hours :P
first mr.pinchy i got in about 500-600 catches and... i lost him
just clicked to fish another too fast and couldnt react, luckily i caught another one in about 30-40 catches :P
1 - Magical Crawdad
2 - Furious Mr. Pinchy
3 - Mr. Pinchy's Blessing
First Mr. Pinchy:
1. Pet (yay!)
2. (...drawing a blank, which one is the increased health 'flask'? Blessing?)
3. Gift
I've caught Mr. Pinchy two times, the first time in BC while stocking up on tank food for our raids. I nabbed the second one only 4 days ago. Honestly, it's rather funny going back after Wrath released, but being an achievement and title nut, this particular achievement was one of three standing in my way of Salty, so it had to be done. Here are the results thus far.
First Mr. Pinchy:
1) Gift (which was only worse because I'm an alchemist)
2) Blessing (which cancelled out my relentless assault buff for the raid we were about to do, stupid on my part)
3) Gift
Second Mr. Pinchy
1) Benevolent
2) Magical Crawdad Pet Box
3) [waiting until tomorrow for making third wish]
1. Furious
2. Pet
3. Blessing
Adys <Salty>, 3 years ago:2nd wipinchy
1. Pet
2. Gift
3. Gift
Ok, this was next on my list of to-do's
Fished in Lake Ere'Noru exclusively
Furious Crawdad - 14
Golden Darter - 3
Enormous Barbed Trout - 1
Spotted Feltail - 1
Mr. Pinchy - 1
First wish out of the box - Pet!
Will let you know other two wishes when they come up
Pinchy no 1:
Gift = Mr. Pinchy's Gift (Containing Mana & Healing Potions)
Furious = Furious Mr. Pinchy
Blessing = Mr. Pinchy's Blessing
Pinchy no 2:
Starts today.....
1st Pinchy:
1) Blessing
2) Pet
3) Gift
1 Mr. Pinchy
1. Gift
2. Pet
1. Gift
1. Pinchy
1. Pet
2. Blessing
3. Furious
You must log in to post.
