Caught my first Pinchy tonight just a bit ago.
Wish 1: Blessing
Since I have to wait two more days, might as well keep fishing...
Wish 2: Pet.
I might keep him for wish 3, since it took a week to get him. I can finally stop farming Pinchy pools incessantly. Only one daily quest stands between me and Salty...just have to wait for the server to choose it.
Hello, I just caught my first Mr. Pinchy. Within 12 hours I had a second one. Here is a list of wishes.
wish 1: from first Mr. Pinchy.
Health buff, some 1200 HPs, or around.
wish 2: actually this wish was first wish from second Mr Pinchy.
Benevolent Mr Pinchy. Nice little pal for a while.
wish 3: from first Mr Pinchy again.
Furious Mr Pinchy. I was in fishing gear, so Stormwind gaurds actually took him down. hehe
wish 4: final wish from first Mr. Pinchy.
BAM! Magical Crawdad box. Pet, achievement, bonus. )
I still have have 2 wishes left on second Mr. Pinchy..... we will see.
Fished for about 2 hours and caught Mr. Pinchy.
Wish 1---Gift
Wish 2---- Benevolent Mr. Pinchy
Wish 3---- Pet : )
good luck fellow Mr. Pinchy fishers
fished mine up after 30min fishing just now..
wish one: pet
other 2 yet to come
Wow!!! I was in Shattrath and am leveling fishing. Currently at 203. On a lark, thought I looked up Mr. Pinchy on here to find the pools to fish, and started hitting them. My 9th catch was Mr. Pinchy, and my first wish granted was the Magical Crawdad Box!
Woot!!!
Fished mine after about 40-50 pool clears. After that one I got a second Pinchy in less than 15 pool clears.
1st Pinchy Furious,Furious,Pet!!!
I pretty much never did that because the fishing is god aweful boring. But this Saturday, a guildie was playing a song over the Ventrillo and I was enjoying the song channel and it got me into a fishing mood. Flew up to one of the mountain lakes. 10 casts later I had Mr. Pinchy. I used a wish and tada... Crawdad box. w00t!
I use the second wish today... we'll see how it goes. 8)
1: gift
2: pet
3: furious
Jeez man just got it! i was reading the guide and came to Blackwind Lake 2nd pool , and got it , the pet that is!
Total pools : 2 :D
Catches : around 7
Me-So-Happy!
Mr. Pinchy #1: Wish Result 1- Pet
Have not and will not use the remaining two wishes.. decided to just keep him for novelty reasons in my tacklebox..
This is my only toon and I just started playing in May..
Just caught my first pinchy today,
first wish was the blessing, 1300hp and got bigger and bright red :)
Will post the other results when i'm allowed to choose again!
On my second wish i just got the magical crawdad box! Yeey :D
Minipuff <Salty>, 4 months ago:5 pinchys caught over about 3 years time on diffrent chars
1st 1 Benevolent 2 gift 3 blessing
2nd 1 pet 2 gift 3 saved last charge for an rainy day
3rd 1 pet 2 gift 3 furious
4th 1 blessing 2 pet 3 gift
5th 1 pet 2 furious 3 blessing
Mr. Pinchy 1: Pet, Benevolent, Gift
HootzJnr <Salty>, 2 months ago:1074 casts and finaly got mr pinchy
i was beggining to think he was dead
wish 1,2,3 all no pet "cry"
edit: i got a second one a few hundred casts later and got pet first try
You must log in to post.
