El's Extreme Anglin' - World of Warcraft Fishing Guide // Forums // Mr. Pinchy's Wishes

[Fishing] Mr. Pinchy's Wishes

21. 

    Deathxtreme <Salty>, 4 years ago:

    The results have been complied up to here. Thank you everyone for contributing to this poll! I'm still missing Wish #3 from Shircon, though...

    If an earlier post is edited, please note the date it was edited so I can update the total results accordingly.

    MR. PINCHY WISHES

    Benevolent: 11
    Furious: 10
    Gift: 13
    Pet: 12
    Blessing: 13

    # Mr. Pinchy's: 20

    So far, it looks like there is an equal change of getting any of the 5 wishes. However, these results should still be taken with a grain of salt considering the small number of Mr. Pinchy's & Wishes. My guess is that people only notice the pet whenever they don't have it (myself included) and think the chance of getting it is lower than the other wishes. So far, though, it looks equally random (although that won't stop anyone from /crying over the lack of a pet...) Keep posting your results, though!

    • Link
22. 

    Crotalidus <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Wish #1: Health buff
    Wish #2: Gift Box
    Wish #3: Furious Mr. Pinchy

    Crotalidus
    Master Angler

    • Link
23. 

    yorkiemum <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    I found 2 mr pinchys today within an hour. I was afraid to see what
    I'd get, so I waited 4 hours to click on it. There was a blast and then
    nothing. I's had my finger in feign death in case furious mr pinchy
    arrived.
    But I saw nothing. Then I happen to notice a box in my back pack
    and realized I had gotten the magical crawdad box. No one was more surprised
    than I was! Both of the mr pinchys share a cool down, so I don't know what
    the other will be.

    It took me 4 years to decided to level fishing, and I've had amazing luck.
    My first quest got me the stormchops, and then the spicy talbuk, and
    an I think broiled bloodfin. I found the crate with the fish finder the first time
    I went hunting for it.
    What I'd like to get are the kibler bits recipe. Maybe my good luck has run
    out tho. lol

    • Link
24. 

    Cynestra <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    It took me a few months, but I eventually caught one. The next day, I caught another. Again, a few months passed, and I caught another one. Once again, the next day, I caught another. So I've caught four so far.

    Mr Pinchy #1;
    Blessing
    Blessing
    Gift

    Mr Pinchy #2
    Blessing
    Gift
    Furious

    Mr Pinchy #3
    Blessing
    To be continued..

    • Link
25. 

    oak <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    mr pinchy 1
    1 - gift
    2 - furious
    3 - benevolent

    mr pinchy 2
    1 - gift
    2 - PET ZOMFG :D
    3 - Benevolent

    that 2 day cd is god-awful

    • Link
26. 

    Jonaleth <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1:
    Benevolent
    Pet
    Buff

    Mr Pinchy #2:
    Buff
    Buff
    Benevolent

    • Link
27. 

    el <Nat Pagle's Love Child>, 4 years ago:

    1. Benevolent
    2. Benevolent
    3. Furious

    Thanks for starting this thread, Deathxtreme. When The Burning Crusade was new, I tried to monitor forum postings about the wishes. My gut feel was that all the wishes had an equal chance. It will be interesting to see what emerges here.

    • Link
28. 

    Telariel <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Caught two Mr. Pinchys!

    Mr. Pinchy 1:

    1. Gift
    2. Gift
    3. Benevolent

    Mr. Pinchy 2:

    1. Gift
    2. Benevolent
    3. Pet!

    • Link
29. 

    Ramaniscence <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Benv
    Pet
    Pet

    • Link
30. 

    Balazar <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Mr. Pinchy #4, alas:

    Furious
    Benevolent
    Gift

    Now have to go fish up #5 to continue to try for the pet.

    • Link
31. 

    Redulon <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Caught my Mr. Pinchy (Dr. Zwicky) yesterday.

    First wish was the Pet.
    2 wishes left for the future :)

    • Link
32. 

    wayth <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Registered so I could post in this thread:

    Pinchy #1
    1) Blessing
    2) Blessing
    3) Blessing

    Pinchy #2
    1) Furious
    2) Gift
    3) to be determined...

    • Link
33. 

    the fishin dead <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    just got my first pinchy ,

    wish1: gift
    wish2: gift
    wish3: benevolent pinchy

    • Link
34. 

    Valkien <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    I have loved Fishing from the time I started WoW 6 months ago. I discoverd this page about 2 months ago and it has really helped me in my quest to "Master" my fishing. Thanks El!

    I hit 70 2 weeks ago and go my flying mount and immediately set out to chatch Mr. Pinchy (to the ringing laughter of my husband and guild mates). After having fished highland pools regularly for the last 2 weeks I caught him Friday afternoon in Lake Jorune (375+Seth's Fishing Pole ,hat, gloves, boots and Bobble)! Also, my fishing quest that night gave me Muchbreath the Crock Pet! What luck!

    On my first wish he gave me the Magical Crawdad Pet! Woot!

    Saturday morning I got up to do my usualy fishing rounds and admire my new little friend, and caught ANOTHER Mr. Pinchy (just over 12 hours apart) this time in Blackwind Lake. So I now have 2 on cooldown, just waiting to see what else I get.

    Second wish yesterday was the Gift Box.

    I am definaltey gonna try the fishing contest this week to se if my fabulous luck will finally allow me to win.

    • Link
35. 

    Dasvampyr <Salty>, 4 years ago:

    Deathxtreme wrote:

    My guess is that people only notice the pet whenever they don't have it

    Not true, of the 4 Mr.Pinchy I already got so far, I got around 4 or 5 pets. a pity they are soulbound or I could had made a small fortune.

    i do not post info about what I got because I don't quite remember exactly what I got and in what exact amounts.

    Cheers and happy fishing

    • Link
36. 

    Shumei <Salty>, 4 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #2:

    Pet, Blessing, Benevolent Mr Pinchy

    • Link
37. 

    Yonah <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    1st cast ever in a highland mixed school = Pinchy !

    #1 benevolent pinchy.
    #2 Blessing
    #3 Blessing :(

    Second Pinchy

    #1 PET!

    I have Another Pinchy got last night....they must like me or something..

    • Link
38. 

    Floyd <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    Hello all,

    I have had this toon (Floyd) for quite some time but never saw fishing to be any more than for food/buffs. Just recently my eyes were open to this completely engrossing new aspect to WoW. My fishing skill is not maxed yet but it is close. I just started fishing for Mr Pinchy this week and caught one on the second day of trying.

    1st wish = Furious Pinchy
    2nd wish = Furious Pinchy
    3rd wish = Magical Crawdad!

    I thought I would go ahead and try the fishing extravaganza this Sunday (yesterday) and won! In addition to the win I also picked up a Brownell's Blue Striped Racer for my Boots! I have been doing the daily fishing quests for only a week now and no goodies from there but I will continue to keep on keepin on.

    • Link
39. 

    Ashling <Angler>, 4 years ago:

    I caught my first Pinchy 2 days ago.

    Wish 1: Furious
    Wish 2: Gift
    Wish 3: Blessing >.<

    Back to the fishing hole.

    • Link
40. 

    chubtohd <Salty>, 4 years ago:

    I've caught 6 Mr Pinchy's over the past several months. My results are as follows and officially put me in the running for the unluckiest wow fisherman ever....

    9 Blessings
    5 Gifts
    3 Furious
    1 Benevolent
    0 Pets :(

    • Link

• RSS

Reply »

You must log in to post.