((Advertisement))

[Fishing] Mr. Pinchy's Wishes

1…345…16

  1. shiny <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Was waiting to post until I finally got the pet. Finally.

    1st Pinchy:
    Benevolent, Gift, Furious

    2nd Pinchy (after roughly 1800 catches):
    Blessing, Furious, Pet

  2. Schrodinger <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    My first pinchy (and only) took me 571 furious crawdad catches (so I think 650 in all).

    1st Pinchy:
    1st wish: Benevolent
    2nd wish: Pet
    3rd wish: Unknown (saving for raid)

  3. Spleen <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1: Pet, Benevolent, Gift

  4. weevil <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    No luck with Mr Pinchy #1 Gift, Furious, Gift

  5. eggs <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1: Blessing, Blessing, Pet
    Mr Pinchy #2: Pet, Benevolent, Furious
    Mr Pinchy #3: Still on cooldown

    Edit:

    Mr Pinchy #3: Pet, Benevevolent, Gift

  6. reginaldo <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1: Furious, Benevolent, Gift
    Mr Pinchy #2: Furious, Furious, Benevolent
    Mr Pinchy #3: Blessing, Benevolent, Benevolent
    Mr Pinchy #4: Benevolent, Blessing, Furious

    Caught my first and second Mr.Pinchy while randomly fishing a few pools I saw while doing dailys in the area. Then decided to grind properly, thought I'd used up all my luck as I easily passed 1k catches before getting him for the third time. Had a few minutes left on my lure so I thought, (you know what's coming right) rather than waste it I'd use it up before leaving. Ten catches later I caught him again.

    Good luck to all fishing for him. Don't give up, the next catch could be the one.

    Bah, four Mr.Pinchys and no pet. I can be found crying in a dark, dark place!

  7. Rigi <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    follow-up since the site's not letting me edit the original post (or i've done something silly):
    last wish of pinchy #4: blessing
    pinchy 5:
    #1: benevolent
    #2: blessing
    #3: pet

    pinchy 6:
    #1: benevolent
    #2: benevolent
    #3: gift

    pinchy 7: TBA

  8. dfvanden <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr. P#1: Benevolent, Benevolent, Benevolent
    Mr. P#2: Benevolent, Pet, Benevolent

  9. Zahana <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Caught my first Mr. Pinchy today
    1st wish - Blessing
    2nd wish - Pet
    3rd wish - Blessing

  10. Warfish <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Caught three Mr. Pinchy thus far. No Pet.

    Pinchy #1:
    -Furious
    -Benevolent
    -Gift (pots)

    Pinchy#2:
    -Benevolent
    -Blessing
    -Furious

    Pinchy#3:
    -Furious
    -Benevolent
    -?????

    Last Wish on my last Pinchy in 48 hours. I best hope for some luck.....

    Took almost 1200 Catches to get my first Pinchy, then the next two came within hours of each other a few days later (maybe 250 catches between the first and the second and third).

  11. Bekkabakoo <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Pinchy #1: Benevolent, Pet, Gift

  12. easterhat <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    My first Pinchy was very disappointing :(

    1 - Gift
    2 - Gift
    3 - Gift :(

    Pinchy No 2 caught 5 mins ago in Skettis

    1 - Gift
    2 -
    3 -

    I think Pinchy has it in for me...

  13. Pallandra <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Pinchy #1:
    1. Furious
    2. Blessing
    3. Blessing

    Pinchy #2
    1. Gift
    2. Blessing
    3. PET!!

  14. Foffa <Salty>, 3 years ago:

    Caught my 2nd Mr Pinchy today. Caught my first a long time ago, and don't remember exactly what i got from it, although i didn't get the pet from any of my 3 wishes.
    I collect pets, and have as of today 51 unique vanity pets on my char, so this 2nd Mr Pinchy really got me excited!

    Mr Pinchy #1 - 1.crap, 2.crap, 3.crap
    Mr Pinchy #2 - 1.blessing, 2.gift, 3.benevolent

    The horror, the horror... :/

    Farming my 3rd Mr P like crazy atm..

  15. rpotor <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Just found this topic and so here are my results so far:

    Mr. Pinchy 1: Furious, Furious, Furious
    Mr. Pinchy 2: Blessing, Furious, Furious

    Seems Mr. Pinchy does not like me, but the feeling is kinda mutual... Anyway I'll get that stupid pet no matter what it takes.

    Also, sorry if it has already been covered elsewhere, but I've heard a rumor that similar to the disappearance of the Amani War Bear mount from the loot tables once the expansion patch hits, Mr. Pinchy would likewise not drop anymore. Is this rumor true or is it just a really bad urban legend?

  16. Ettelen <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1 - Gift, Furious, Blessing
    Mr Pinchy #2 - Furious, Gift, Furious
    Mr Pinchy #3 - Benevolent, Benevolent, Blessing

  17. Alyssheart <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    Mr Pinchy #1 gift, gift, benevolent
    Mr Pinchy #2 gift, gift, gift

    yeah working on a 3rd. I have single handedly fed all my tanks and heals trying to get this pet =รพ

  18. Peppep <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    1. Benevolent
    2. Benevolent
    3. Gift

  19. varran <Angler>, 3 years ago:

    ok so never finish telling what i got from my first so :
    1-buff
    2-buff
    3-gift

    and second one:
    1-buff
    and 2 more on c/d...hopefully ill get that pet

  20. Balazar <Moderator>, 3 years ago:

    Well, after taking a bit of a break, I started up on my attempts again. On my first pool, second cast, Mr. Pinchy! This is my fifth one now, in an attempt to get the pet.

    First wish was Benevolent Mr. Pinchy. Waiting for the others.

1…345…16

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Forums Index